November18

You know what they say. Once you give something a name, you get attached. It’s inevitable.
Case in point: As you may recall, “Bobby” the pumpkin joined our household last month, and there was never a more beloved vegetable. Since the day he left the pumpkin patch, Bobby became immersed in Noah’s world of three-year-old play: engaging Bionicles in battle, observing the finer points of Lego architecture, watching Cars, listening to stories, and sleeping in a big boy bed. As I watched Noah tuck Bobby in for his nap, swaddling him in his favorite striped blanket, I realized that my boy had signed Bobby’s adoption papers with what he thought was permanent ink.
Only one problem: Bobby was approaching his expiration date, and quickly. His skin, once firm to the touch, bent inward with the slightest pressure. His complexion was mottled and bruised. It was only a matter of time before he collapsed in on himself, going the way of all gourds.
I tried to prepare Noah gently, using numerous approaches:
Casual: “Yup, it’s about time to get rid of our pumpkins.” (This remark sent Noah into tears, and possibly therapy.)
Spiritual: “Noah, God knows how much you love your pumpkin. He will give you a new pumpkin someday.” (More tears. Noah doesn’t want a new pumpkin; he wants Bobby.)
Scientific: “You know, Noah, Bobby is full of seeds. Bobby is rotting on the outside, but his insides are full of seeds that we can plant in the ground. Then Bobby will grow back as a brand new pumpkin next year.” (Apparently the concept of cutting Bobby open was too horrifying to consider.)
Sentimental: “How about we take a picture of Bobby that you can keep in your room?”
Thinking this to be the best solution, I positioned Bobby on Noah’s bedspread, careful to capture him on his best side. I had snapped just a photo or two when Noah intervened, snatching Bobby up in his arms.

Together they cowered in a corner. (Notice that Noah’s shorts are on backwards, which is painfully precious.)

“Bobby doesn’t want his picture taken,” Noah said firmly, like a press secretary calming a media frenzy. Bobby had no comment.

Noah’s anxiety over Bobby’s demise only grew worse. One afternoon, as I read aloud from “The Velveteen Rabbit,” his expression darkened and his eyes filled with tears. I had just gotten to the part where the doctor tells the nanny that the old rabbit had to be burned. Noah was inconsolable.
“I’m sad about Bobby,” he cried, his face crumpled in genuine grief.
“I know, Buddy,” I said, rubbing between his shoulder blades.
It felt a little silly, all this fuss about a pumpkin, but to Noah the loss was real. I hated being the one to tell him that pumpkins don’t last forever, almost as much as I hated sneaking Bobby from his room, slipping him into a plastic bag, and discarding him in an outdoor trash can. I felt like a murderer attempting to hide the body.
But love, like a pumpkin, is filled with seeds, and a child’s soul is fertile ground for new beginnings. This morning as I scanned through a batch of old pictures, Noah spotted one with a pumpkin in the background. “Is that pumpkin like Bobby?” he asked, eyes wide and wondering.
I tensed. “Yes, just like Bobby.”
He considered this: the ghost of pumpkins past. “Oh,” he replied. Then he picked up his action figures and began to play.
And that was our goodbye to Bobby.